Tuesday, July 31, 2012
Japan govt names radiation physicist as new atomic regulator head
From Reuters: Japan govt names radiation physicist as new atomic regulator head
* Appointments aimed at boosting shattered public confidence in nuclear power
Friday, July 27, 2012
Our Political Black Hole
From the New York Times, Op Ed: Our Political Black Hole
Scientists in Geneva announced this week that they had found a new subatomic particle that they were 99.999999 percent sure was the elusive Higgs boson, nicknamed the “God particle.” Even though we had no earthly idea what that meant, we were definitely excited.
Scientists in Geneva announced this week that they had found a new subatomic particle that they were 99.999999 percent sure was the elusive Higgs boson, nicknamed the “God particle.” Even though we had no earthly idea what that meant, we were definitely excited.
It’s given us so much to think about: how existence began, the structure
of the universe, the difference between bosons and fermions. And, of
course, what it will mean to the presidential race.
The first thing all patriotic Americans are going to want to know is why
something this important happened elsewhere. The Large Hadron Collider,
where the physicists did the work, was built by the European
Organization for Nuclear Research. We were building a Superconducting
Super Collider of our own, in Waxahachie, Tex., but Congress stopped the
financing for it in 1993.
“It’s disheartening that a large number of fairly intelligent people
could do such a thing,” said Leon Lederman, a Nobel Prize-winning
physicist, when the budget-cutting House of Representatives ended the
program. This was, of course, a long time ago, back when Americans still
undertook expensive, daring construction projects and believed the
House of Representatives had a large number of fairly intelligent
people.
But about the Higgs boson. As Dennis Overbye explained in The Times, it
is “the only manifestation of an invisible force field, a cosmic
molasses that permeates space and imbues elementary particles with
mass.” And we have so many questions. Does it provide evidence of the
existence of parallel worlds? If so, is it possible to move to one that
doesn’t have Michele Bachmann?
Most of all, however, we want to know who this helps in the election:
WOLFEBORO, N.H. — Mitt Romney today denounced Barack Obama for allowing
Europe to beat the United States at particle physics research. Under his
administration, Romney vowed, “All particles that bind the earth
together will be discovered in America, by Americans and for Americans.”
Under questioning from reporters, Romney said that his favorite kind of subatomic particle is the fermion.
SOMEWHERE ON A BUS — Speaking to a crowd of blue-collar workers in Ohio,
President Barack Obama hailed the scientific news from Geneva as “a
great moment in history, not unlike my rescue of the auto industry.” The
physicists who made the discovery, Obama noted, all had health
insurance.
TRENTON — Gov. Chris Christie today called for the privatization of the
Higgs boson. “Binding the earth together is something that could be
handled much more efficiently by the for-profit sector,” the Republican
governor and deeply available vice-presidential prospect said.
“Auctioning off the rights to the Higgs boson will create American jobs
and balance American budgets.”
When a reporter noted that the boson was discovered in Switzerland, Christie called him “stupid” and “off-topic.”
CEDAR FALLS, IOWA — Rick Santorum today denounced the European
Organization for Nuclear Research for discovering something that is
nicknamed the God particle. “If God had wanted there to be a particle,
he’d have given it to Adam and Eve,” said Santorum, who is traveling
through the Hawkeye State this week because, really, he doesn’t have
much else to do.
WOLFEBORO, N.H. — Aides to Mitt Romney said the former governor’s
favorite kind of subatomic particle is actually the boson.
SOMEWHERE ELSE ON A BUS — President Barack Obama told a crowd of
blue-collar workers that there have been more Higgs bosons discovered
during his administration than during those of both George Bushes
combined.
WOLFEBORO, N.H. — Mitt Romney said today that when he called for an
American effort to beat the Europeans in particle physics research, he
did not actually mean spending money to build a supercollider, but
merely “the need for our physicists to think harder.” The Republican
presidential contender said he believed this could be accomplished by
“the elimination of onerous, physics-research-killing regulations.”
JUST OUTSIDE OF WOLFEBORO, N.H. — Protesters today passed out cartoons
of Mitt Romney with a large, cuddly looking Higgs boson strapped to a
crate on the front of his jet ski.
WASHINGTON — Surrogates for Barack Obama and Mitt Romney sparred over
the meaning of the potential discovery of the Higgs boson. On “Meet the
Press,” Gov. Bobby Jindal of Louisiana called it “a questionable throw
of the dice by the same folks who gave us the euro.”
On “Face the Nation,” David Axelrod, the Obama campaign communications
director, said that if the Large Hadron Collider had been acquired by
Bain Capital it would have been “burdened with debt and sold for scrap
metal” and that Romney would be “the most anti-physics president since
Franklin Pierce.”
NEW YORK — Donald Trump told reporters that “my people in Hong Kong”
have uncovered evidence that America’s failure to take the lead in
subatomic particle research was because of a conspiracy between the
Obama administration and unnamed Chinese industrialists. He also said
that he had invited the Higgs boson to be a contender on “All-Star
Celebrity Apprentice.”
Wednesday, July 25, 2012
Hawking lost $100 on Higgs discovery bet
From Sky News: Hawking lost $100 on Higgs discovery bet
Renowned British physicist Stephen Hawking says the Nobel
Prize should be given to Peter Higgs, the man who gave his name to the
Higgs boson particle.
Renowned British physicist Stephen Hawking says the Nobel
Prize should be given to Peter Higgs, the man who gave his name to the
Higgs boson particle.
Former Cambridge University professor Hawking also joked that the discovery had actually cost him $100 in a bet.
In
an interview with the BBC Wednesday, Hawking, who has motor neurone
disease, said: 'This is an important result and should earn Peter Higgs
the Nobel Prize.
'But it is a pity in a way because the great advances in physics have come from experiments that gave results we didn't expect.
'For
this reason I had a bet with Gordon Kane of Michigan University that
the Higgs particle wouldn't be found. It seems I have just lost $100.'
After
half a century of research, physicists announced at the European
Organisation for Nuclear Research (CERN) Wednesday they had found a new
sub-atomic particle consistent with the elusive Higgs boson which is
believed to confer mass.
Hawking said the discovery was of major importance.
'If
the decay and other interactions of this particle are as we expect, it
will be strong evidence for the so-called standard model of particle
physics, the theory that explains all our experiments so far,' Hawking
said.
Monday, July 23, 2012
A Blip That Speaks of Our Place in the Universe
From : The New York Times: A Blip That Speaks of Our Place in the Universe
ASPEN, Colo. — Last week, physicists around the world were glued to computers at very odd hours (I was at a 1 a.m. physics “party” here with a large projection screen and dozens of colleagues) to watch live as scientists at the Large Hadron Collider, outside Geneva, announced that they had apparently found one of the most important missing pieces of the jigsaw puzzle that is nature.
ASPEN, Colo. — Last week, physicists around the world were glued to computers at very odd hours (I was at a 1 a.m. physics “party” here with a large projection screen and dozens of colleagues) to watch live as scientists at the Large Hadron Collider, outside Geneva, announced that they had apparently found one of the most important missing pieces of the jigsaw puzzle that is nature.
The “Higgs particle,”
proposed almost 50 years ago to allow for consistency between
theoretical predictions and experimental observations in elementary
particle physics, appears to have been discovered
— even as the detailed nature of the discovery allows room for even
more exotic revelations that may be just around the corner.
It is natural for those not deeply involved in the half-century quest
for the Higgs to ask why they should care about this seemingly esoteric
discovery. There are three reasons.
First, it caps one of the most remarkable intellectual adventures in
human history — one that anyone interested in the progress of knowledge
should at least be aware of.
Second, it makes even more remarkable the precarious accident that
allowed our existence to form from nothing — further proof that the
universe of our senses is just the tip of a vast, largely hidden cosmic
iceberg.
And finally, the effort to uncover this tiny particle represents the
very best of what the process of science can offer to modern
civilization.
If one is a theoretical physicist working on some idea late at night or
at a blackboard with colleagues over coffee one afternoon, it is almost
terrifying to imagine that something that you cook up in your mind might
actually be real. It’s like staring at a large jar and being asked to
guess the number of jelly beans inside; if you guess right, it seems too
good to be true.
The prediction of the Higgs particle accompanied a remarkable revolution
that completely changed our understanding of particle physics in the
latter part of the 20th century.
Just 50 years ago, in spite of the great advances of physics in the
previous half century, we understood only one of the four fundamental
forces of nature — electromagnetism — as a fully consistent quantum
theory. In just one subsequent decade, however, not only had three of
the four known forces succumbed to our investigations, but a new elegant
unity of nature had been uncovered.
It was found that all of the known forces could be described using a
single mathematical framework — and that two of the forces,
electromagnetism and the weak force (which governs the nuclear reactions
that power the sun), were actually different manifestations of a single
underlying theory.
How could two such different forces be related? After all, the photon,
the particle that conveys electromagnetism, has no mass, while the
particles that convey the weak force are very massive — almost 100 times
as heavy as the particles that make up atomic nuclei, a fact that
explains why the weak force is weak.
What the British physicist Peter Higgs and several others showed is that
if there exists an otherwise invisible background field permeating all
of space, then the particles that convey some force like
electromagnetism can interact with this field and effectively encounter
resistance to their motion and slow down, like a swimmer moving through
molasses.
As a result, these particles can behave as if they are heavy, as if they
have a mass. The physicist Steven Weinberg later applied this idea to a
model of the weak and electromagnetic forces previously proposed by
Sheldon L. Glashow, and everything fit together.
This idea can be extended to the rest of particles in nature, including
the protons and neutrons and electrons that make up the atoms in our
bodies. If some particle interacts more strongly with this background
field, it ends up acting heavier. If it interacts more weakly, it acts
lighter. If it doesn’t interact at all, like the photon, it remains
massless.
f anything sounds too good to be true, this is it. The miracle of mass —
indeed of our very existence, because if not for the Higgs, there would
be no stars, no planets and no people — is possible because of some
otherwise hidden background field whose only purpose seems to be to
allow the world to look the way it does.
Dr. Glashow, who along with Dr. Weinberg won a Nobel Prize
in Physics, later once referred to this “Higgs field” as the “toilet”
of modern physics because that’s where all the ugly details that allow
the marvelous beauty of the physical world are hidden.
But relying on invisible miracles is the stuff of religion, not science.
To ascertain whether this remarkable accident was real, physicists
relied on another facet of the quantum world.
Associated with every background field is a particle, and if you pick a
point in space and hit it hard enough, you may whack out real particles.
The trick is hitting it hard enough over a small enough volume.
And that’s the rub. After 50 years of trying, including a failed attempt
in this country to build an accelerator to test these ideas, no sign of
the Higgs had appeared. In fact, I was betting against it, since a
career in theoretical physics has taught me that nature usually has a
far richer imagination than we do.
Until last week.
Every second at the Large Hadron Collider, enough data is generated to
fill more than 1,000 one-terabyte hard drives — more than the
information in all the world’s libraries. The logistics of filtering and
analyzing the data to find the Higgs particle peeking out under a
mountain of noise, not to mention running the most complex machine
humans have ever built, is itself a triumph of technology and
computational wizardry of unprecedented magnitude.
The physicist Victor F. Weisskopf — the colorful director in the early 1960s of CERN,
the European Organization for Nuclear Research, which operates the
collider — once described large particle accelerators as the gothic
cathedrals of our time. Like those beautiful remnants of antiquity,
accelerators require the cutting edge of technology, they take decades
or more to build, and they require the concerted efforts of thousands of
craftsmen and women. At CERN, each of the mammoth detectors used to
study collisions requires the work of thousands of physicists, from
scores of countries, speaking several dozen languages.
Most significantly perhaps, cathedrals and colliders are both works of
incomparable grandeur that celebrate the beauty of being alive.
The apparent discovery of the Higgs may not result in a better toaster
or a faster car. But it provides a remarkable celebration of the human
mind’s capacity to uncover nature’s secrets, and of the technology we
have built to control them. Hidden in what seems like empty space —
indeed, like nothing, which is getting more interesting all the time —
are the very elements that allow for our existence.
By demonstrating that, last week’s discovery will change our view of
ourselves and our place in the universe. Surely that is the hallmark of
great music, great literature, great art ...and great science.
¶
Saturday, July 21, 2012
'God-particle' Nobel Prize winning Pakistani physicist shunned in own country over religious beliefs
From Newstrack India: 'God-particle' Nobel Prize winning Pakistani physicist shunned in own country over religious beliefs
London, July 10 (ANI): Abdus Salam (died in 1996) , the first Pakistani to win a Nobel Prize in physics after he predicted the existence of the so-called 'God particle', had been shunned in his own country because of his religious beliefs.
Salam had predicted the existence of the Higgs-Boson particle in the 1970s but despite being a leading figure in Pakistan's Space and Nuclear Program, he was shunned by Muslim fundamentalists when they took control of the country during those years.
According to the Daily Mail, although Salam was a Muslim, the physicist, who died in 1996, belonged to the Ahmadi sect, who believed Hadrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad was their spiritual leader as opposed to the Prophet Muhammad.
As a result Salam, along with Pakistanis from other religious minorities, such as Shiite Muslims, Christians and Hindus were attacked by militants from the Sunni Muslim majority.
The physicist's life, along with the fate of the three million other Ahmadis in Pakistan, drastically changed in 1974 when parliament amended the Constitution to declare that members of the sect were not considered Muslims under Pakistani law.
Salam resigned from his government post in protest and eventually moved to Europe to pursue his work and created a centre in Italy for theoretical physics to help physicists from the developing world.
He reportedly received a string of international prizes and honours for his groundbreaking work in the world of subatomic physics, while in 1979, he shared the Nobel Prize with Steven Weinberg for his research on the Standard Model of particle physics, which theorized that fundamental forces govern the overall dynamics of the universe.
Salam died on 21 November 1996 at the age of 70 in Oxford, England, after a long illness.
London, July 10 (ANI): Abdus Salam (died in 1996) , the first Pakistani to win a Nobel Prize in physics after he predicted the existence of the so-called 'God particle', had been shunned in his own country because of his religious beliefs.
Salam had predicted the existence of the Higgs-Boson particle in the 1970s but despite being a leading figure in Pakistan's Space and Nuclear Program, he was shunned by Muslim fundamentalists when they took control of the country during those years.
According to the Daily Mail, although Salam was a Muslim, the physicist, who died in 1996, belonged to the Ahmadi sect, who believed Hadrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad was their spiritual leader as opposed to the Prophet Muhammad.
As a result Salam, along with Pakistanis from other religious minorities, such as Shiite Muslims, Christians and Hindus were attacked by militants from the Sunni Muslim majority.
The physicist's life, along with the fate of the three million other Ahmadis in Pakistan, drastically changed in 1974 when parliament amended the Constitution to declare that members of the sect were not considered Muslims under Pakistani law.
Salam resigned from his government post in protest and eventually moved to Europe to pursue his work and created a centre in Italy for theoretical physics to help physicists from the developing world.
He reportedly received a string of international prizes and honours for his groundbreaking work in the world of subatomic physics, while in 1979, he shared the Nobel Prize with Steven Weinberg for his research on the Standard Model of particle physics, which theorized that fundamental forces govern the overall dynamics of the universe.
Salam died on 21 November 1996 at the age of 70 in Oxford, England, after a long illness.
Thursday, July 19, 2012
'The Real Work Has only Just Begun'
From der Spiegel.com: 'The Real Work Has only Just Begun'
In a SPIEGEL interview, physicist Rolf-Dieter Heuer, general director of the particle physics research center at CERN near Geneva, discusses the remaining unsolved mysteries in his field following the spectacular discovery of the Higgs boson.
In a SPIEGEL interview, physicist Rolf-Dieter Heuer, general director of the particle physics research center at CERN near Geneva, discusses the remaining unsolved mysteries in his field following the spectacular discovery of the Higgs boson.
SPIEGEL: Mr. Heuer, now that the Higgs boson has finally been discovered at CERN, are there plans to shut down the particle accelerator?
Heuer: By no means. We have achieved a breakthrough, but the real
work has only just begun. We need to measure our find, observe its
interaction with other particles and also determine its properties. And
if, when doing that, we find something that contradicts our theory, then
that will automatically open the door to a new type of physics. After
all, our so-called Standard Model only describes 4 to 5 percent of our
universe.
SPIEGEL: And the rest?
Heuer: About one-fourth is made up of dark matter. It's what keeps the rotating galaxies from simply flying apart. That cannot be explained with visible matter alone. What we call dark energy accounts for the almost three-fourths that remain. It causes the universe to expand at an ever faster rate. But we still don't understand the mechanism which expands space equally in all directions.
SPIEGEL: Could the Higgs provide new clues?
Heuer: The Higgs field, which is part of the particle, has a decisive characteristic that fits with dark energy: It works in all directions simultaneously.
SPIEGEL: So Higgs could be the bridgehead to the unknown?
Heuer: Precisely. We don't know if it has anything to do with dark energy. But we suspect that there is a similar field beyond the Standard Model -- the other end of the bridgehead, so to speak.
SPIEGEL: And what if Higgs doesn't do you the favor of revealing such secrets?
Heuer: We will still have found a particle that helps provide all other particles with mass. It finally proves that our Standard Model is completely accurate. What we must do now is find the hole in this model through which we can advance to the remaining 95 percent of the universe. We still don't know what role the particle we have found plays. It's like catching sight of your best friend from a distance. At first it could also be someone who looks a lot like that person, but it turns out to be someone totally different. You only find out for sure when you get closer.
SPIEGEL: What do you plan to do next?
Heuer: By the end of the year, we plan to fire protons at each other. Then we will shut down the accelerator for around two years for maintenance work. When it goes back into commission, things will get exciting: Step by step we will double the energy, allowing us to create particles with ever greater mass. And it could be that by doing so, we will also exceed the threshold to dark matter. That would open new doors.
SPIEGEL: What do you hope to find?
Heuer: Primarily the first traces of supersymmetry. That's the name of the theory which holds that every particle also has a shadow particle -- a mirror world predicted by the theory of anti-matter. Supersymmetry's lightest particle could be stable enough to be within the reach of our accelerator. That would be a good candidate for dark matter. If we find it, it would represent a massive leap forward.
SPIEGEL: Do you know exactly where you need to search? Or do you just look randomly?
Heuer: Both. We have to be entirely open to unexpected findings. Still, with supersymmetry, we already have a direction and our search is targeted. But it will no longer be as focused as it was with Higgs.
SPIEGEL: When searching for Higgs, you essentially had a ready-made profile of the particle, the one published by Peter Higgs in 1964. Does he deserve the Nobel prize?
Heuer: I think so. But there are also others who were working on similar models back then …
SPIEGEL: … while the Nobel rules only allow for a maximum of three prize winners at a time.
Heuer: Yes, that needs to be changed. In many areas of research -- from particle physics to genetics -- ever larger groups of people work together because that's the only way it can work. At some point, the time will have passed when individuals are capable of major discoveries.
SPIEGEL: How many researchers were involved in the long journey towards finding Higgs?
Heuer: In the end, between three and four thousand took part in each of the two major participating experiments.
SPIEGEL: Are such large groups able to change focus and commit to new goals? Or will each researcher soon go back to doing his or her own thing?
Heuer: No, our people will surely stick with it, especially now. The ability to work together has to be in the blood of particle physicists. They learn very early on that it is impossible to advance on one's own and that constant exchange is necessary.
SPIEGEL: Doesn't an individual's achievements get lost in the crowd?
Heuer: No, it is still very easy to identify an excellent physicist. Good people climb quickly -- just like in a company.
SPIEGEL: How large can research teams be and still remain manageable?
Heuer: Fifteen years ago, I led a project with 350 people. At the time we thought that was the upper end. Now we have 10 times as many. I would say the real limits we are experiencing are in technology and in the detectors that we are capable of building.
SPIEGEL: For how much longer will you be able to continue conducting experiments with the Large Hadron Collider? At which point will it have done its duty?
Heuer: We are planning up until 2030. It may be worthwhile to
upgrade the machine again during the 2020s -- for a relatively low extra
investment, we would then be able to collide considerably more
particles. But it depends on what we have found by that time.
SPIEGEL: And afterwards? Will you need even bigger machines?
Heuer: It's the energy, and not the size, that is decisive. The closer we want to look, the faster we have to accelerate the particles. In our case, it's the protons. A lot suggests that our next undertaking will be an accelerator that fires electrons at positrons. That would open up a new view of matter, and of the Higgs particle. There are already plans for it. The main question is which region of the world would be ready to build such a machine?
Interview conducted by Manfred DworschakHeuer: About one-fourth is made up of dark matter. It's what keeps the rotating galaxies from simply flying apart. That cannot be explained with visible matter alone. What we call dark energy accounts for the almost three-fourths that remain. It causes the universe to expand at an ever faster rate. But we still don't understand the mechanism which expands space equally in all directions.
SPIEGEL: Could the Higgs provide new clues?
Heuer: The Higgs field, which is part of the particle, has a decisive characteristic that fits with dark energy: It works in all directions simultaneously.
SPIEGEL: So Higgs could be the bridgehead to the unknown?
Heuer: Precisely. We don't know if it has anything to do with dark energy. But we suspect that there is a similar field beyond the Standard Model -- the other end of the bridgehead, so to speak.
SPIEGEL: And what if Higgs doesn't do you the favor of revealing such secrets?
Heuer: We will still have found a particle that helps provide all other particles with mass. It finally proves that our Standard Model is completely accurate. What we must do now is find the hole in this model through which we can advance to the remaining 95 percent of the universe. We still don't know what role the particle we have found plays. It's like catching sight of your best friend from a distance. At first it could also be someone who looks a lot like that person, but it turns out to be someone totally different. You only find out for sure when you get closer.
SPIEGEL: What do you plan to do next?
Heuer: By the end of the year, we plan to fire protons at each other. Then we will shut down the accelerator for around two years for maintenance work. When it goes back into commission, things will get exciting: Step by step we will double the energy, allowing us to create particles with ever greater mass. And it could be that by doing so, we will also exceed the threshold to dark matter. That would open new doors.
SPIEGEL: What do you hope to find?
Heuer: Primarily the first traces of supersymmetry. That's the name of the theory which holds that every particle also has a shadow particle -- a mirror world predicted by the theory of anti-matter. Supersymmetry's lightest particle could be stable enough to be within the reach of our accelerator. That would be a good candidate for dark matter. If we find it, it would represent a massive leap forward.
SPIEGEL: Do you know exactly where you need to search? Or do you just look randomly?
Heuer: Both. We have to be entirely open to unexpected findings. Still, with supersymmetry, we already have a direction and our search is targeted. But it will no longer be as focused as it was with Higgs.
SPIEGEL: When searching for Higgs, you essentially had a ready-made profile of the particle, the one published by Peter Higgs in 1964. Does he deserve the Nobel prize?
Heuer: I think so. But there are also others who were working on similar models back then …
SPIEGEL: … while the Nobel rules only allow for a maximum of three prize winners at a time.
Heuer: Yes, that needs to be changed. In many areas of research -- from particle physics to genetics -- ever larger groups of people work together because that's the only way it can work. At some point, the time will have passed when individuals are capable of major discoveries.
SPIEGEL: How many researchers were involved in the long journey towards finding Higgs?
Heuer: In the end, between three and four thousand took part in each of the two major participating experiments.
SPIEGEL: Are such large groups able to change focus and commit to new goals? Or will each researcher soon go back to doing his or her own thing?
Heuer: No, our people will surely stick with it, especially now. The ability to work together has to be in the blood of particle physicists. They learn very early on that it is impossible to advance on one's own and that constant exchange is necessary.
SPIEGEL: Doesn't an individual's achievements get lost in the crowd?
Heuer: No, it is still very easy to identify an excellent physicist. Good people climb quickly -- just like in a company.
SPIEGEL: How large can research teams be and still remain manageable?
Heuer: Fifteen years ago, I led a project with 350 people. At the time we thought that was the upper end. Now we have 10 times as many. I would say the real limits we are experiencing are in technology and in the detectors that we are capable of building.
SPIEGEL: For how much longer will you be able to continue conducting experiments with the Large Hadron Collider? At which point will it have done its duty?
Heuer: It's the energy, and not the size, that is decisive. The closer we want to look, the faster we have to accelerate the particles. In our case, it's the protons. A lot suggests that our next undertaking will be an accelerator that fires electrons at positrons. That would open up a new view of matter, and of the Higgs particle. There are already plans for it. The main question is which region of the world would be ready to build such a machine?
Wednesday, July 18, 2012
TIME Talks to the Physicists Who Found the Higgs
From Time Science: TIME Talks to the Physicists Who Found the Higgs
It's not often that the world stops, cheers and generally goes nuts over a new discovery in particle physics. But that's what happened on July 4, when physicists from the European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN) announced that they had at last confirmed the existence of the elusive Higgs boson, the particle that gives the universe mass. The Higgs suffuses an energy field that permeates space, and as particles move though it, they acquire a degree of mass that corresponds to their own energy level. Failing to find the Higgs would not only have meant that a new theory would have to be developed, but that the standard model of particle physics — one of the great pillars of the field for the past several decades — would fall apart.
But the Higgs was indeed run to ground, thanks to work conducted at the massive new Large Hadron Collider (LHC), which straddles the border of Switzerland and France (read more about it in the new issue of TIME,). Thousands of physicists from dozens of countries contributed to the work, but there are three undisputed leaders: Joe Incandela and Fabiola Gianotti, who led the two research teams that made the discovery; and Rolf Heuer, CERN's Director General. TIME spoke to them all by phone in Melbourne, Australia, where just three days earlier they had presented their momentous findings to the International Conference on High Energy Physics.
TIME: So you did it. Almost 50 years after the Higgs was first theorized, you found it. How does that feel?
Gianotti: First of all, we are happy. To me personally this event is an arrival point and departure point. It's an arrival point because it's been the dream of all of us. But there's more. It brings more physics beyond the standard model. Among the questions we have in mind: dark matter, antimatter and matter symmetry. It's a very nice reward for the work.
Heuer: It does open as many questions as it answers. You always find an answer but this answer usually gets you to more questions.
Gianotti: provided you know the right question to ask.
Incandela: If you look at all the particles we've discovered before, they're either matter particles or copies of them. But the Higgs involves what makes up the universe. I give lectures to the public and say what we're searching for is the genetic code of the universe.
TIME: Of those other doors the Higgs could open, one of the most tantalizing involves dark matter, the as-yet unidentified force or particle that makes up 80% of the universe and holds the galaxies together gravitationally. How can the Higgs help?
Incandela: Dark matter enters in a funny way. Any particle at the subatomic level is constantly interacting with other particles in space time. Some of this is described through supersymmetry, in which sets of particles exactly parallel other particles but cancel out some of the mass. Dark matter enters because we believe that in supersymmetry the lightest supersymmetric particle doesn't decay. This is the dark matter. When you do the calculation it almost perfectly matches the mass or density for the amount of dark matter we think is in the universe.
TIME: And what about dark energy — the even less-understood force that contributes to the expansion of the universe?
Heuer: The Higgs would be the first fundamental scalar which we have in our hands. A scalar has zero spin — it has no preferred direction. If you are swimming in a river, the force exerted on you by the water is different depending on which way you're swimming. If you're in a swimming pool there's no preferred direction. The Higgs must be a scalar, or mass would depend on the direction a particle is moving. Dark energy must be a scalar too because dark energy moves in all directions. So now we have two scalars. We might with these be able to determine the nature of fundamental scalars.
TIME: What was it about the Higgs that made it such a consuming goal for physicists? After all, the field has looked for — and found — other particles before.
Heuer: It's not just another type of particle.
Gianotti: The top quark was discovered in 1995 and since then the Higgs has become our obsession because the standard model was incomplete with out it. We had to understand things like why the top quark was so heavy and the electron is so light. The Higgs is a big, important step.
Heuer: The difference between finding the top quark and the Higgs was that we knew the top quark had to be there but for the Higgs we were wishing it would be there but it didn't have to be. One thing that's important to say is that if we had excluded the Higgs in the energy range of the LHC we would have found its replacement. But it would have taken much longer because we wouldn't know its nature.
TIME: Had you begun to worry that you indeed might not find it?
Incandela: Only in the past few years did I begin to worry. Once we started in the LHC we eliminated a huge amount of space so quickly [in the particle weight spectrum.] We looked between 100 and 600 GeV [billion electron volts] and had only about a 15 GeV rage around 125. That's all that was left.
TIME: And that's right where you found it. What there a particular moment that you realized you'd succeeded?
Incandela: We were working so hard to put everything together, but when we unblinded the data and saw a big signal, I realized we had something. But I was reserved. The work was not done until I walked into the room [at the Melbourne meeting.] As I was giving the presentation and showed the distribution, it hit me. We really discovered this thing! It wasn't just that I had the moment, it was having the whole community and they believed it. If you get married by a judge in his office it's not like a church wedding.
Heuer: For me it's a little bit different. I'm not in the details. I have to be neutral. We had the agreement that they come to my office and show me their data and nothing leaks out. When I saw the first plot from Joe and the first plot from Fabiola, I thought 'OK, we have it.' They didn't know their own discovery. I had to spell it out to them. They were very resistant to use the world discovery, but I persuaded them, yes, it is a discovery. We can use discovery.
It's not often that the world stops, cheers and generally goes nuts over a new discovery in particle physics. But that's what happened on July 4, when physicists from the European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN) announced that they had at last confirmed the existence of the elusive Higgs boson, the particle that gives the universe mass. The Higgs suffuses an energy field that permeates space, and as particles move though it, they acquire a degree of mass that corresponds to their own energy level. Failing to find the Higgs would not only have meant that a new theory would have to be developed, but that the standard model of particle physics — one of the great pillars of the field for the past several decades — would fall apart.
But the Higgs was indeed run to ground, thanks to work conducted at the massive new Large Hadron Collider (LHC), which straddles the border of Switzerland and France (read more about it in the new issue of TIME,). Thousands of physicists from dozens of countries contributed to the work, but there are three undisputed leaders: Joe Incandela and Fabiola Gianotti, who led the two research teams that made the discovery; and Rolf Heuer, CERN's Director General. TIME spoke to them all by phone in Melbourne, Australia, where just three days earlier they had presented their momentous findings to the International Conference on High Energy Physics.
TIME: So you did it. Almost 50 years after the Higgs was first theorized, you found it. How does that feel?
Gianotti: First of all, we are happy. To me personally this event is an arrival point and departure point. It's an arrival point because it's been the dream of all of us. But there's more. It brings more physics beyond the standard model. Among the questions we have in mind: dark matter, antimatter and matter symmetry. It's a very nice reward for the work.
Heuer: It does open as many questions as it answers. You always find an answer but this answer usually gets you to more questions.
Gianotti: provided you know the right question to ask.
Incandela: If you look at all the particles we've discovered before, they're either matter particles or copies of them. But the Higgs involves what makes up the universe. I give lectures to the public and say what we're searching for is the genetic code of the universe.
TIME: Of those other doors the Higgs could open, one of the most tantalizing involves dark matter, the as-yet unidentified force or particle that makes up 80% of the universe and holds the galaxies together gravitationally. How can the Higgs help?
Incandela: Dark matter enters in a funny way. Any particle at the subatomic level is constantly interacting with other particles in space time. Some of this is described through supersymmetry, in which sets of particles exactly parallel other particles but cancel out some of the mass. Dark matter enters because we believe that in supersymmetry the lightest supersymmetric particle doesn't decay. This is the dark matter. When you do the calculation it almost perfectly matches the mass or density for the amount of dark matter we think is in the universe.
TIME: And what about dark energy — the even less-understood force that contributes to the expansion of the universe?
Heuer: The Higgs would be the first fundamental scalar which we have in our hands. A scalar has zero spin — it has no preferred direction. If you are swimming in a river, the force exerted on you by the water is different depending on which way you're swimming. If you're in a swimming pool there's no preferred direction. The Higgs must be a scalar, or mass would depend on the direction a particle is moving. Dark energy must be a scalar too because dark energy moves in all directions. So now we have two scalars. We might with these be able to determine the nature of fundamental scalars.
TIME: What was it about the Higgs that made it such a consuming goal for physicists? After all, the field has looked for — and found — other particles before.
Heuer: It's not just another type of particle.
Gianotti: The top quark was discovered in 1995 and since then the Higgs has become our obsession because the standard model was incomplete with out it. We had to understand things like why the top quark was so heavy and the electron is so light. The Higgs is a big, important step.
Heuer: The difference between finding the top quark and the Higgs was that we knew the top quark had to be there but for the Higgs we were wishing it would be there but it didn't have to be. One thing that's important to say is that if we had excluded the Higgs in the energy range of the LHC we would have found its replacement. But it would have taken much longer because we wouldn't know its nature.
TIME: Had you begun to worry that you indeed might not find it?
Incandela: Only in the past few years did I begin to worry. Once we started in the LHC we eliminated a huge amount of space so quickly [in the particle weight spectrum.] We looked between 100 and 600 GeV [billion electron volts] and had only about a 15 GeV rage around 125. That's all that was left.
TIME: And that's right where you found it. What there a particular moment that you realized you'd succeeded?
Incandela: We were working so hard to put everything together, but when we unblinded the data and saw a big signal, I realized we had something. But I was reserved. The work was not done until I walked into the room [at the Melbourne meeting.] As I was giving the presentation and showed the distribution, it hit me. We really discovered this thing! It wasn't just that I had the moment, it was having the whole community and they believed it. If you get married by a judge in his office it's not like a church wedding.
Heuer: For me it's a little bit different. I'm not in the details. I have to be neutral. We had the agreement that they come to my office and show me their data and nothing leaks out. When I saw the first plot from Joe and the first plot from Fabiola, I thought 'OK, we have it.' They didn't know their own discovery. I had to spell it out to them. They were very resistant to use the world discovery, but I persuaded them, yes, it is a discovery. We can use discovery.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)